A supplier quotes £12.60 for a metal bracket. Last year, you paid £11.40. The supplier says its costs have gone up. Before agreeing to the increase, ask which costs went up and by how much. Even a rough breakdown can narrow down what you need to check.
A should-cost model gives you a way to work through that question. You estimate what it would cost to make the part at the volume you need, then allow for the supplier’s profit. You’re working with estimates, so the number you come up with is a starting point for a conversation. It can show whether a change in materials, batch size or the work included in the quote might explain the new price.
Price the part as it’s actually made
Start with the drawing and the quantity on the quote. A bracket that needs a finish on both sides may take more work than one that only needs coating on the visible face. If you’re comparing this year’s price with last year’s, pull up both specifications. Check whether the supplier is still being asked to do the same job. Use the same quantity in both comparisons.
Say you’re buying 1,000 brackets in one run. For this example, allow £4.80 a unit for metal, including scrap after any recoverable value. Estimate £2.40 for labour and £1.50 for machine time. Add £0.90 for factory overhead that isn’t already covered by the labour or machine rates. That gives you £9.60 a bracket before setup.
If the run costs £600 to set up, spread that over all 1,000 units. It adds 60p a bracket, taking the estimated cost to £10.20. Add an illustrative 15% markup on cost and the model comes to £11.73. That markup is an assumption for this example. It gives a gross margin of about 13% on the modelled selling price, assuming £10.20 is the full cost of goods sold per bracket.
Caventis’s guide to should-cost modelling shows how to build up materials, labour and other cost inputs. If you’re putting the numbers in a spreadsheet, give each input a short note on where it came from. A recent price for the same grade of metal is a different sort of evidence from a guess about how long a machine will run.
What a second production run adds
The £11.73 estimate leaves an 87p gap against the supplier’s £12.60 quote. That’s £870 on 1,000 brackets. It may be tempting to take that number into a negotiation straight away. First, check which assumption could move it most.
Suppose the supplier has priced two runs of 500 because you asked for deliveries in separate months. If it needs to set up from scratch for each run, you’ve allowed £600 too little across the order. Setup now costs £1.20 per bracket. Keeping the other assumptions and the markup the same, the estimate rises to £12.42. The difference between your model and the quote is now 18p a unit.
That’s a different conversation. Check why the supplier needs two runs. If the finished brackets can be stored without damage, the gap between the delivery dates may matter more to the buyer than to the factory. Ask whether the supplier can make all 1,000 in one run and deliver them in two batches. If it can, find out whether it will charge to hold the second batch and when you’ll pay for it. You can then compare the cost of the extra setup with the cost of holding stock and paying for it earlier.
Put the gap to the supplier
You can ask a useful question without sharing the whole spreadsheet. Try asking what the price would be for a single run of 1,000, with delivery dates unchanged. If you suspect the coating specification is driving the increase, ask what changed in that operation. The supplier may point to an extra inspection, a tighter tolerance or work that used to be charged separately. Put anything that changes your estimate back into the model before drawing a conclusion.
A second quote can help when the cost is still hard to explain. Send the other factory the same drawing and ask for prices at both run sizes. Check what each quote includes, especially setup and inspection. Caventis’s product sourcing service explains how it tenders against a common specification and qualifies suppliers before comparing offers.
There’s also a point at which more detail won’t help. If you can only estimate machine time within a wide range, run the model at both ends of that range. For example, if machine time could cost anywhere from £1.30 to £1.70 per bracket, the two-run estimate would range from £12.19 to £12.65. At £12.60, the quote sits near the top of that range. It’s worth checking the cycle time before asking for a price cut. Keep delivery outside this calculation unless you include it on both sides. For the brackets, start by asking whether the quote includes one setup or two.