Elite Membership

How the CRA Chooses Which Tax Returns to Audit

Written by WSM Creative Team WSM Creative Team WallStreetMojo Contributor Writes WallStreetMojo articles with practical finance, Excel, valuation, and business learning context. View Full Profile
Reviewed by Dheeraj Vaidya, CFA, FRM Dheeraj Vaidya, CFA, FRM Content Reviewer & Course Director Dheeraj is a former J.P. Morgan and CLSA Equity Analyst with nearly two decades of experience in financial modeling, valuation, equity research, and corporate finance. He specializes in helping students and professionals develop practical and in-demand finance skills through structured and AI-powered, 20+ Years of experience CFA, FRM, IIT Delhi, IIM Lucknow Financial Modeling View Full Profile
Updated Nov 20, 2026
Read Time 7 min

Photo by Windows on Unsplash

Alt text: Person working at a desk with a laptop and printed papers, reviewing financial records in a bright office

CRA Audit Selection at a Glance

  • Most CRA audits start with a risk assessment, so a file is usually picked because something in it stood out.
  • Your employer, your bank, and the apps you sell through all report to the CRA, and your return gets checked against what they sent.
  • Big jumps from one year to the next, or numbers that look very different from similar businesses, are what tend to stand out.
  • Good records, kept for at least six years, can help an audit move faster if one ever comes.

It’s easy to assume an audit letter from the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) is just bad luck. In most cases, it has more to do with what’s in your return. The CRA picks files based on a risk assessment, which looks at how likely a return is to contain errors and whether anything suggests taxes aren’t being paid as they should be.

Often, what stands out is a gap between what you reported and what the CRA already knows from other sources. Taxpage’s list of what triggers a CRA audit covers the risk factors observed over four decades of Canadian tax practice. 

How Does the CRA Decide Which Files to Review?

The CRA doesn’t share its formula, but it does explain what goes into it. It looks at the information it already has on you and may compare your return with similar files. It can also use what it learns from other audits. So if your business partner, a supplier, or a company you’re connected to gets audited, that can sometimes lead to a look at your return too.

Your past returns matter as well. Say you own a rental property and your expenses doubled this year, but the rent stayed the same. Or maybe you’re a contractor whose profit margin is well below what other contractors report. Either one can get flagged, even when there’s a perfectly good reason behind it.

The CRA Hears About Your Income From Others

A lot of what goes on your tax return has already been reported by someone else. Your employer sends the CRA a copy of your T4. Your bank and investment accounts send slips like the T5 for interest and dividends. If the income on your return doesn’t match those slips, the CRA can follow up.

Apps are part of this now too. Since January 1, 2024, platforms where people sell goods, offer services, or rent out property have had to report their sellers’ information to the CRA, including how much they paid each seller. So if you earn money through a short-term rental, ride-share, or online selling app, the CRA can see that total. Reporting all of it keeps your numbers in line with theirs.

Selling property works the same way. Under the residential property flipping rule, if you sell a home in Canada that you’ve owned for less than 365 days, the profit is treated as business income, not a capital gain. There are exceptions for certain life events, like a death in the family or a move for work. Since the CRA has access to property details, a quick sale reported as a capital gain can stand out.

Patterns That Can Lead to a Closer Look

What gets attention is usually a mismatch between two sets of numbers. Here are some common ones:

  • You report less income than your slips or app reports show for the same year.
  • Your expenses, like vehicle or meal costs, take up a much bigger share of your revenue than they do for similar businesses.
  • Your profit drops sharply from one year to the next, even though your sales stay about the same.
  • Your spending or the property you own doesn’t seem to fit the income you report, and the CRA can see things like credit history and property details.
  • You post lifestyle to social media

None of these mean you did anything wrong. A slow year or a big equipment purchase can explain a lot, and an audit gives you the chance to show that with your records.

What Happens if Your Return Is Selected?

An auditor will reach out by mail, phone, or both, and tell you which period they want to look at. They may ask for business records like ledgers, invoices, contracts, and bank statements. They may also want personal records, like mortgage papers or credit card statements.

If the auditor thinks something needs to change, you’ll get a proposal letter first. You then have 30 days to agree or explain why you don’t. If you still can’t sort it out, you can talk to the auditor’s team leader, as the CRA’s audit guide explains. And if you disagree with the final reassessment, you can dispute it by filing a notice of objection.

Good Records Make an Audit Easier

By law, you need to keep your books and records, usually for at least six years. If you keep them on a computer, they have to stay readable. The CRA says good records help an audit move faster, while missing ones can slow it down.

The CRA’s page on keeping records lays out what to keep and for how long, and it’s worth a read before tax season. Set up a simple system for your receipts, slips, and app statements. That way, if a letter ever does show up, everything you need will already be in one place.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Far Back Can the CRA Audit a Tax Return?

For most people, the CRA has three years from the date on your notice of assessment to reassess a return. This is called the normal reassessment period. It’s four years for mutual fund trusts and for corporations that aren’t Canadian-controlled private corporations. The CRA can go back further in some cases, like when a misrepresentation on a return came from neglect, carelessness, or wilful default, when there was fraud, or when you signed a waiver.

Can the CRA Look at My Spouse’s or Family’s Records?

Yes, in some cases. If records belonging to someone else relate to the return being audited, the auditor can ask to see them. The CRA’s audit guide mentions records of a spouse or common-law partner, family members, corporations, partnerships, and trusts. The auditor may also talk to whoever handles your bookkeeping, so it helps if everyone involved knows how your books are kept.

Do I Need to Report Income That Didn’t Come With a Slip?

Yes, taxable income has to be reported whether or not you got a slip for it. That includes cash payments, tips, side jobs, and online sales. It helps to keep your own records of these amounts, like bank deposits or app statements, so you can report them accurately and back them up if the CRA ever asks.

What Should I Do if I Spot a Mistake on a Return I Already Filed?

You can usually fix it yourself, either online through My Account or by sending the CRA a written request with supporting documents. It’s better to correct a mistake before the CRA finds it. If the problem is bigger, like income missing from several years of returns, the CRA’s Voluntary Disclosures Program may be an option. Talk to a tax professional before you apply, since who qualifies and what relief you get depend on your situation.

How Long Does a CRA Audit Take?

It varies from file to file. The CRA says the length depends on things like how organized your records are, how much the audit covers, delays from missing documents, and whether other CRA specialists need to weigh in. If some records are gone, you’ll be expected to try to get copies from your bank or suppliers. If that’s not possible, the auditor can work with you on other ways to confirm your numbers.

This article is general information only, not legal or tax advice, and reflects the rules as of this writing (November 2026).