What is the Enron Scandal?
The Enron Scandal involves Enron duping the regulators by resorting to off-the-books accounting practices and incorporating fake holding. The company utilized special purpose vehicles to hide its toxic assets and big amounts of debts from the investors and creditors.
The Enron corporation was regarded as a corporate giant. But after a good run, it failed miserably and ended up as a bankrupt business. The failure and bankruptcy of the Enron Corporation jolted Wall Street as well as it put several employees on the verge of the financial crisis. The corporation had massive debts in its name. It tried to conceal these with the help of special economic entities as well as special purpose vehicles. Enron traded at the highest market price of $90.75 at the period of December 2, 2001. And when the accounting scandalAccounting ScandalAccounting Scandals refer to situations which demonstrate intentional falsification or misrepresentation of financial documents. Some of the most famous ones are by Enron, Freddie Mac, HealthSouth, & American Insurance Group etc. emerged, stock prices went down to a record low of $0.26 per share.
Rise of Enron Scandal
The scandal began with the Enron misdeeds in the video rental chains. The business collaborated with a blockbuster to penetrate the VOD market. After entering the market, the business overstated the earnings basis for the growth of the VOD market.
The business executed $350 billion in trades, but it did not last long as the dot com bubble came in. It spends a significant amount on broadband projects, but the business was unable to recover costs from the spending made. The company was exposed to massive exposures, and investors lost money as market capitalization deteriorated.
In 2000, the business started to crumble. CEO Jeffrey Skilling concealed all financial losses resulting from the trading business and broadband projects by applying the accounting concept of mark-to-market accounting. The company kept building assets. It reported profits that were yet to be earned. If the actual profit earned were less than the reported earningsEarningsEarnings are usually defined as the net income of the company obtained after reducing the cost of sales, operating expenses, interest, and taxes from all the sales revenue for a specific time period. In the case of an individual, it comprises wages or salaries or other payments., the loss was never reported. Additionally, the business transferred the asset to the off-the-books corporation. Like this, the corporation concealed their losses.
To add to the agony, the chief financial officer of the business Andrew Fastow deliberately resorted to the plan that displayed that the business is in good financial shape even though its subsidiaries lost a lot of investor’s money.
Summary of Enron Scandal with Timeline of Downfall
#1 – Business Background
The year was 1985, and Enron was incorporated as the merger of Houston Natural Gas company and Internorth Ince. In 1995, the business was recognized as the most innovative business by the Fortune, and it made it successful run for the next six years. In 1998, Andrew Fastow became the CFO of the business, and the CFO created SPVs to conceal the financial losses of the Enron. During the period of 2000, the shares of Enron traded at the price levels of $90.56.
#2 – Initial Ripples
On February 12, 2001, Jeffrey Skilling came in place of Kenneth as a chief executing officer. On August 14, 2001, Skilling abruptly resigned, and Kenneth took over the role once again. Same period, the broadband division of the business reported a massive loss of $137 million, and the market prices of stock fell to $39.05 per share. In the period of October, the CFO ‘s legal counsel instructed auditorsAuditorsAn auditor is a professional appointed by an enterprise for an independent analysis of their accounting records and financial statements. An auditor issues a report about the accuracy and reliability of financial statements based on the country's local operating laws. to destroy the files of the Enron and asked to maintain only the utility or necessary information. The business reported a further loss of $618 million and a write off of $1.2 billion. The price of the stock deteriorates to $33.84.
#3 – Fall of Giant
On October 22, the business got into a probe from securities and exchange commission. With this news, the stock of Enron further deteriorated and was reported at $20.75. In November 2001, the business for the first time admitted and made the revelation that it inflated its income levels by $586 million. Also that it has been doing so since 1997. On 2nd December 2001, the business files for bankruptcy and the stock prices end up flat at $0.26 per share.
#4 – Criminal Probe
On January 9, 2002, the justice department ordered a criminal proceeding against the business. On January 15, 2002, the NYSE suspended Enron, and the accounting firm, along with Arthur Andersen was convicted on the grounds of obstruction of justice.
Enron Scandal Causes
- The creation of a special purpose vehicle for concealing financial losses and a pile of financial debt;
- Mark-to-market accounting as an accounting concept is an excellent method to value securities, but such a concept becomes a disaster when applied to the actual business.
- Lapse of corporate governanceCorporate GovernanceCorporate governance is a set of rules or practices through which an entity is directed and controlled to increase shareholders wealth by increasing the economic value and is concerned about its relations with various entity stakeholders. in Enron Corporation.
Enron Hiding their Debt
The Enron corporation and its management resorted to an unethical scheme and malpractice of off-balance-sheet mechanism. It created a special economic vehicle to hide the massive debt from its external stakeholders, namely creditors and investors. The special purpose vehicle was utilized for concealing realities of accounting rather than focussing on the operating results.
The corporation transferred some portion of assets that had rising marketable value to the special economic vehicle, and in return, it took cash or note. The special purpose vehicle then utilized to such stock to hedge an asset present on the balance sheet of Enron. It ensured that a special purpose vehicle reduced the counterparty risk.
The formation of the special purpose vehicles can not be termed as illegal, but in comparison with the securitization techniques relating to debt, it could be termed as bad. Enron disclosed the existence of special purpose vehicles to the investors and the public, but few people understood the complexity of transactions done using the special purpose vehicles.
Enron assumed that the prices of the stock would continue to appreciate and that it would not deteriorate or fail as hedge funds. The primary threat was that the special economic entities were capitalized with only the stock of the corporation. If the corporation was compromised, then the special economic entities won’t be able to hedge the deteriorating market price of such stocks. Additionally, the Enron corporation had held significant conflicts of interest with respect to the special purpose vehicles.
MTM in Enron Scandal
The CEO of Enron corporation Jeffrey Skilling transitioned the accounting practice of the Enron corporation from a historical cost accounting method to mark to market accounting method. The transition of the accounting practice received approval from the securities and exchange commission during 1992. Mark to market accounting is a practice that reports the fair market value of the liabilities and assets for a given duration or financial period.
The mark to market gives insights to an institution and is regarded as the legitimate practice. The method, however, is also exposed to some form of manipulation. The Mark to market is based on fair value rather than taking up the actual value. It caused the business to fail miserably as they were reported the expected profits as the actual profits.
Why is the Enron Scandal Important?
The Enron scandal is significant in terms of learning perspectives for both new financial professionals and experienced professionals. The scandal tells us why strong corporate governance is the key to success for any business to sustain and drive profitable business. Additionally, it draws insights as to how accounting policies should not be used and applied. Any misuse can have drastic results or impacts on the health of the business.
Due to the bankruptcy of the business, employees lost several perks and pension benefits. Many came on the verge of the financial crisis. The crisis was so deep that the shareholders of the business lost an estimated value of $74 billion. Such corporate fraud should be taken as learning, and an understanding should be drawn as to why regulations and compliance are necessary.
The Enron corporation was formed as the merger of Houston’s natural gas company and inter-north incorporation. After the merger, it grew rapidly and was regarded as the most innovative company. However, it resorted to bad accounting practices. It was involved in the creation of special purpose vehicles, utilized to hide the rising debt of the Enron incorporation, and this led to the failure and downfall of the business.
This article has been a guide to What is the Enron Scandal?. Here we discuss the summary of Enron Scandal along with its causes timeline downfall and importance. You can learn more about from the following articles –